• Got ADHD?

    theresa


    Theresa Lode or, simply “T”, had her world turned upside down and inside out when her son was diagnosed with ADHD and a few other goodies. Her choice- follow the doctor's orders....or trust her heart and delve into the world of Free Range Education. She chose the latter...

    Curious? Want to know more? Read on ...
  • Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

    Join 191 other followers

  • Your email is safe with me. No exceptions!

  • Blog Stats

    • 37,399 hits
  • Meta

Perhaps the box is the problem

This past week Molly and Caleb took their first ever standardized tests.  It was the TCAPs- Tennessee’s way of measuring our kids, their teachers and their school administrators.

The testing protocol was quite rigid they reported.  Don’t look around.  Pick up your pencil when told.  No coughing or nose blowing allowed.  And when you’re done- sit and wait.

Molly told me how hard it was to just sit their and stare at her desk for 30 or more minutes since she finished the tests rather quickly. And I feel bad for the teachers.  I can’t imagine that when the teachers envisioned their future as educators, this is the picture that came to mind.

What’s more disturbing to me is how we have come to accept this as normal, yea verily, even healthy for the kids.

High performance on a standardized test is no indicator of future success.  But yet in all the smoke and mirrors and gobbly gook of academic yabber, we’re led to believe this is a good thing.

True indicators of success include: Perseverance, good relationship skills, curiosity and resourcefulness.  Stuff that can never be quantified on a test.

This compelling desire to box up our children and quantify them like some sort of factory widget has been around for a long time.

Theodoris Van Gogh had this perspective.  He felt that if his son didn’t fit the mold…his son was the problem, not the mold. Tsk, tsk.  I’m grateful his boy followed his heart; how about you?

Do you suppose Vincent would have done well on the TCAPs?

Hey! Be sure and join Deb Ingino and I for a chat about learning differences THIS THURSDAY at 9:00 pm cst.  Cut and paste the link in the right sidebar for all the info.  We’re going to have a lot of fun!

Standardized minds

There is a new policy at Molly’s school innocuously called, “Not There Yet.”   It mandates a minimum 80% on all tests and quizzes for 7th and 8th graders.  Is it a stretch to imagine that this policy is driven by the Tennessee Comprehensive Assessment Program? (TCAP)

Failure to obtain an 80% results in a mandatory “remediation” session after school until the 80% is obtained.  Failure to do that results in a three hour detention.  By gosh by golly…This kids WILL learn!

So what’s wrong with this?  Shouldn’t this assure me my child is in a quality educational program?   Isn’t the “Not There Yet” campaign part of an effort to ensure children are absorbing the material?

How much time do you have?

When I think of the children that will never be test takers or the boys who need to work with their hands or the creative souls that need expression…it sickens me to think THIS is how they will judged.

Standardized testing is an irrelevant measurement tool and is not a predictor of future success.

Unless of course you’re looking to train a population who knows how to obey and regurgitate information.  And to focus on test scores as the Holy Grail of academic achievement is as foolish as preparing our kids for a job market that was last seen hoofing it to India.

Yes, a baseline of academic material is important, especially in the technical age we live in. (And I could argue about HOW that information is obtained but that is for another day.) But more accurate indicators of success include qualities like: Creativity, likeability, and ingenuity. And what about life skills such as cooking from scratch or building a house?  And what about curiosity?

These are things that will never be measured on a standardized test and I contend:

The mind is a terrible thing to standardize.


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 191 other followers